Floridacycling.com is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

The 14 Best Comfortable Bike Seats

bike-seats

People enjoy cycling for a variety of reasons from fitness and weight loss through to recreational riding, racing, touring, and commuting.

While you can expect almost all bikes to come with some form of seat included, not all bike seats are created equal. Additionally, not all bike seats are designed with comfort in mind.

So, whatever your reasons for cycling and whatever type of bike you ride, today’s guide will show you how to navigate the best comfortable bike seats to find one that delivers the comfiest possible riding experience.

If you are encountering any pain, discomfort, or numbness while riding your bike, it could be time to upgrade the saddle.

Now, while it might not superficially appear like the most challenging piece of bike equipment to buy, there are several pointers to consider when comparing comfy bike seats.

  • The type of riding you will do: You should think about the distances you cycle, the intensity of your rides, and the terrain you will ride on when choosing a bike seat. Commuters and recreational riders may look for more padding and may be prepared to accept a heavier saddle. Longer distance cyclists should look for sleek seats promoting optimum power transfer when pedaling. If you ride a mountain bike, look for a saddle that features efficient shock absorption and that is built to cope with more demanding terrain.
  • Seat width: When choosing bike seats, remember that the seat needs to be wide enough to support your rear, but without impeding your ability to properly pedal. Larger riders may appreciate wide and oversized saddles when looking for the most comfortable ride.
  • Materials: Most bike saddles, even those classified as comfortable saddles, are made from one of two types – foam or gel cushioning. A foam saddle is firmer, responsive, and ideal for longer rides. The heavier you are, the thicker the foam you should look for in a comfort saddle. Saddles stuffed with gel cushioning, by contrast, are a smart choice for commuters looking for maximum comfort to the exclusion of all other factors. This type of saddle is not suitable for longer rides, though.
  • Padding: Soft and thick padding can introduce pressure on your nerves and sit bone during longer rides. This leads to pressure points developing and a reduction in the power you can develop while pedaling.
  • Cutout: A cutout or relief channel in a bike saddle is not essential, although some riders prefer this design of seat since it reduces soft tissue pressure. Most saddles with cutouts are gender-specific.

If you keep these simple points in mind when comparing bike seats, we are confident you’ll find the most appropriate saddle for you needs. Dive in!


The 14 Best Comfortable Bike Seats

1. Our Pick: Giddy Up! Comfortable Bike Saddle

Giddy-Up!-Bike-Seat

Features

  • Material: Faux leather
  • Weight: 2.1 pounds
  • Dimensions: 11 x 4.3 x 8.35 inches

First up today and our favorite comfortable bike saddle comes from Giddy Up! How does this seat shape up, then?

The first thing you’ll appreciate is the width of this saddle. The oversized fit works especially well for larger riders who are often frustrated by the narrow construction of many regular bike saddles.

Made from artificial leather that’s both supple and hardwearing, the key benefit when it comes to comfort is the gel padding inside this seat. The memory foam will adapt to your preferred riding position. Padding is extra-thick to support your tailbone as you ride.

Like all the best bike saddles, this fits almost any bike, including indoor bikes. Easy to install, all mounting tools are bundled along with an adapter. This gives you everything you need to get going right out the box and to start riding right away.

A nice extra on this saddle is the strip of LED lighting at the rear. Keep yourself seen when riding in gloomy conditions without needing a tail light on your bike.

If you frequently leave your bike outside when it is raining or you ride in wet conditions, you’ll be glad of the protective and waterproof cover included with this saddle.

This seat is only available in black, so you’ll need to look elsewhere if you insist on a vibrantly colored bike seat.

While we can’t describe this as a cheap bike seat, it costs far less than you might imagine considering the quality and comfort served up.

Things We Like

  • Extra-wide seat
  • Soft and plush padding
  • LED lights on rear

Things We Dislike

  • Not ideal for riding long distances

2. Bikeroo Oversized Bike Seat

Bikeroo-Oversized-Bike-Seat

Features

  • Material: Faux leather
  • Weight: 2.1 pounds
  • Dimensions: 10.2 x 10.2 x 7 inches

Bikeroo make a wide range of saddles for all purposes, so how does this comfort model stand and fall?

Well, like the seat above, this one is wide enough to accommodate larger riders without compromising comfort or safety.

You’ll first need to choose between an indoor or outdoor version. This iteration is the outdoor variant that features steel springs. The indoor alternative is equipped with elastomer springs.

There is no choice of colors with this saddle beyond the regulation black common to most bike seats. If this is a deal-breaker, we review plenty of more colorful options below.

When it comes to the type of bike the saddle fits, though, your choice is much wider. Whether you have a mountain bike, a road bike, a fixed gear bike, or a touring bike, this seat should be a snug fit.

Made from a durable but comfortable faux leather, the wide seat is softly padded to help ease aches and pains, even if you’re riding longer distances.

As with all the best seats for your bike, this one comes with a waterproof cover bundled to maximize lifespan.

The saddle also features robust steel springs that provide decent shock absorption, ideal if you often ride your mountain bike on rocky trails.

While this seat performs strongly across the board, the frame is the weak point here. Setting this aside, you’re getting a rugged and comfy saddle at a pretty keen price from a brand you can rely on.

Things We Like

  • Steel spring suspension
  • Wide but lightweight seat
  • Waterproof cover supplied

Things We Dislike

  • Fragile seat frame

3. TONBUX Comfortable Bike Seat

TONBUX-Most-Comfortable-Bicycle-Seat

Features

  • Material: Nylon blend
  • Weight: 2.1 pounds
  • Dimensions: 9.6 x 3.7 x 7.8 inches

TONBUX might not be the first brand that springs to mind when you think of bike seats, but what do you get if you take a chance on an unknown?

In terms of price, this seat falls at the upper end of the budget range, but when it comes to performance, it punches above its weight.

Choose from a plain black saddle or one of three brightly colored accents. This seat has bright red to contrast with the black.

The outer of the saddle is made from faux leather, probably the most common of all materials for bike seats. Artificial leather combines comfort and durability without costing as much as genuine leather.

Additionally, you’ll benefit from a highly effective memory foam inside this saddle. The foam will conform to your body as you pedal, becoming increasingly comfortable over time.

At the base of the cushion, you’ll find a pair of shock absorbing balls to help reduce some of the vibration you’ll experience from the road or trail.

Where many bike seat manufacturers have awkward returns policy, this one doesn’t. If you’re not happy with the seat or if you don’t find it comfortable enough, return it for a no-quibbles refund. What this means is that you really have nothing to lose by treating yourself to this saddle.

Things We Like

  • Responsive memory foam build
  • Several vibrant colorways
  • Tough but supple construction

Things We Dislike

  • Stability issues reported

4. Brooks England Cambium Bike Seat

Brooks-England-Cambium-All-Weather-Bike-Seat

Features

  • Material: Nylon blend
  • Weight: 2.1 pounds
  • Dimensions: 11.1 x 5.5 x 2.1 inches

Not everyone is looking for the cheapest bike seats, so next up comes a saddle for those with more exacting tastes and more fluid budgets.

The Brooks England Cambium comes in a choice of standard or carved configuration. This is the carved version featuring a substantial cutout.

Equipped with a fully waterproof nylon cover designed to withstand the elements, this seat only comes in black.

Where the back plates of some saddles are weak and fragile, this seat is finished in fiberglass and is effectively reinforced. You’ll also get loops on the back plate to accommodate your saddle bag or any other small accessories.

The main portion of the saddle is made from a vulcanized rubber blended with organic cotton canvas for a winning combination of comfort and longevity.

While almost all user feedback concerning the saddle itself is glowingly positive, the returns policy of this manufacturer means you should think closely before committing to purchase. With a costly saddle like this, you expect a seamless returns policy.

The saddle is lightweight enough not to weigh you down but solid and robust enough to withstand plenty of punishment, even if you’re riding long distances on the road.

Although this might not be the comfiest of saddles in this class, you’ll gain in terms of aerodynamics, performance, and lifespan.

Things We Like

  • Waterproof seat top
  • Strong fiberglass back plate
  • Flexible and forgiving

Things We Dislike

  • Problematic returns policy

5. Bikeroo Bike Seat Cushion

Bikeroo-Bike-Seat-Cushion

Features

  • Material: Polyester and gel
  • Weight: 0.8 pounds
  • Dimensions: 11 x 1 x 10 inches

Next up is another offering from the Bikeroo stable with this pocket-friendly model. As an added bonus, the seat is currently discounted, so act quickly and you could grab yourself a real bargain for the last few weeks of summer.

The saddle comes in a choice of four colors to match your bike. You must also choose between the large or narrow saddle. Designed with comfort uppermost, this is the wide version and highly recommended for anyone prioritizing comfort over aerodynamics.

The outside of the seat is made from polyester, a material renowned for its hardwearing properties. The cover of the seat is waterproof and has an anti-slip feature to stop you from sliding around in the saddle as you ride.

Whether you have an indoor or outdoor bike, you should find this saddle is a near-universal fit.

Aside from the non-premium materials – and we expect that at this price point – the only other meaningful drawback with this seat is the way it tends to move from side to side. Think about the type of cycling you undertake and ask yourself whether this would be a deal-breaker.

As a welcome change to much of the competition, this brand delivers first-class customer service as well as a comfortable and long-lasting bike saddle. What are you waiting for?

Things We Like

  • Multiple bright colors
  • Soft gel outer
  • Ideal for indoor or outdoor riding

Things We Dislike

  • Seat prone to moving from side to side

6. Selle Royal Men’s Soft Bike Saddle

Selle-Royal-Men's-Respiro-Soft-Moderate-Saddle

Features

  • Material: Gel blend
  • Weight: 1.2 pounds
  • Dimensions: 10.9 x 7.17 x 3 inches

Next in line is the Selle Royal Respiro. Named for the respirational channel running through the center, this seat is described by the manufacturer as a soft-moderate saddle.

Like many high-end bike seats, this one is finished in no-nonsense black with no other choice of colors available.

The main selling point here is the channel designed to promote high respiration as you cycle while at the same time alleviating any pressure to the perineal area as you ride.

The cover on the seat is designed to stay cooler than competing models, perfect if you often spend extended periods in the saddle, whether for racing or leisure purposes.

Overall construction is impressive. The sealed nature of the unit makes it entirely waterproof and a great option if you live somewhere where it rains frequently.

Memory gel inside the seat is the main comfort-related benefit. Also, this foam will conform to the contours of your body, making it one of the best comfortable bike seats in this vertical.

At the back of the seat, a clip system is designed to snugly accommodate Selle Royal saddle bags and other accessories, ideal for longer rides.

Although the saddle is a strong contender out the box, build quality issues may develop over time. This seat does not have a reputation for being the longest-lasting out there, so buyer beware.

Things We Like

  • Respirational channel is highly effective
  • Attachment clip at the rear of saddle
  • Sealed and fully water resistant

Things We Dislike

  • Some reported lifespan issues

7. YLG Oversized Bike Seat

YLG-Oversized-Comfort-Bike-Seat

Features

  • Material: Leather, foam, and gel
  • Weight: 2.5 pounds
  • Dimensions: 15 x 13 x 7 inches

As we reach the midpoint of today’s bike seat reviews, we have an oversized offering from YLG. Priced in the mid-range, you’re getting great value, solid performance, and above all maximum comfort.

Made extra-wide, the seat is designed with your comfort uppermost. This version is intended for outdoor bikes. If you ride a Peloton or similar indoor bike, there is a saddle available from YLG. You can also opt for a model equipped with a taillight, ideal if you don’t already have bike lights.

Inside the seat is a soft and padded memory foam. This is intended to conform to your body, promoting comfort when riding longer distances.

Although this version of the comfy saddle doesn’t come with a taillight, there is a reflective band offering at least some extra visibility when it’s dark outside.

Despite the generous width of this saddle, you shouldn’t find your leg rotation or hip movement is impeded.

Designed to fit just about any bike, you get the adapter you need to install the seat in minutes flat. The manufacturer recommends this seat for use with the following bikes:

  • Mountain bikes
  • Cruisers
  • Road bikes
  • Commuter bikes
  • Tourers

With such a wide choice of bike styles and almost universal fit, this is one of the few bike saddles you can confidently buy online without worrying about whether it is compatible with your bike.

Shock absorbers should ensure you get an even smoother ride and complete a winning package at a budget-friendly price point. As an inbuilt benefit, you get a lengthy 90-day returns window, too, eliminating any anxiety from purchasing online.

Things We Like

  • Wide seat without compromising hip movement
  • Efficient shock absorption
  • Super-simple installation

Things We Dislike

  • Not the best choice for lengthy rides

8. Zacro Bike Seat Cushion

Zacro-Bike-Seat-Cushion-Gel-Padded-Bike-Seat

Features

  • Material: Polyester
  • Weight: 0.44 pounds
  • Dimensions: 8 x 1.2 x 11 inches

Zacro offers a soft and comfy bike saddle that’s priced firmly in budget territory, but is it any good?

Anyone looking for a bright and fun seat is in luck with several vibrant colorways available in addition to the standard issue black.

The key benefit of this saddle is the soft gel inside, allowing you to feel more comfortable during longer bike rides.

Although designed for outdoor bikes, the seat will also fit most indoor bikes and spinning bikes, giving you a great deal of versatility.

Like all the best comfortable bike saddles, you get everything you need to mount this model included. Installation takes minutes and the overall stability of the seat is commendable.

This is not the widest saddle in this class, so larger riders may want to explore some of the oversized bike seats we review today.

While not a major issue, the cover of this saddle tends to slide off, so think carefully about your intended use before investing in a seat that could be unsuitable for your purposes.

Things We Like

  • Soft gel construction
  • Ideal for spinning or indoor cycling
  • Easy to mount saddle

Things We Dislike

  • Cover prone to slipping off

9. Volt Saddle

WTB-Volt-Saddle

Features

  • Material: Cromoly
  • Weight: 2.1 pounds
  • Dimensions: 10.4 x 5.6 x 2.4 inches

Volt is a brand famous for its domination of the e-bike vertical. With this mountain bike saddle, the company show they can also perform strongly when it comes to traditional bikes.

Made from cromoly, the main draw with this saddle is the padding. The helix padding comes with gel inserts, meaning you shouldn’t get fatigued in the saddle even when cycling longer distances. The inserts are thoughtfully positioned to prevent your bones from contacting the saddle.

The tail of this seat curves slightly upward, while there is a slight dip to the nose. This is designed to promote better comfort and stability when riding trailheads.

The rail is made from cromoly, a material often used for BMXs. Other versions of this saddle use different materials for the rail.

In addition to providing outstanding comfort, this seat is also lightweight and aerodynamic, a winning formula from a brand you can trust.

Things We Like

  • Soft but supportive saddle
  • Intelligently positioned gel inserts
  • Relatively lightweight build

Things We Dislike

  • Sizing discrepancies flagged

10. BLUEWIND Bike Seat

BLUEWIND-Bike-Seat,-Bicycle-Saddle

Features

  • Material: Faux leather and gel
  • Weight: 1.7 pounds
  • Dimensions: 10.9 x 9.25 x 5.7 inches

As we near the end of today’s guide to the most comfortable bike seats, another artificial leather model, this time from BLUEWIND.

We appreciate that everyone has different budgets and requirements when buying bike accessories and equipment, so this model is intended for beginners and those with limited budgets who are not prepared to compromise comfort in a bike saddle.

Like all faux-leather seats, you’ll get comfort married to durability here. Choose from one of eight colorways to suit.

Inside the seat is where the comfort is apparent thanks to the soft but responsive memory foam. Just like the memory foam in beds, this will conform to your body’s contours over time.

At the back of the saddle is a robust triangular frame designed with lifespan in mind.

With a pair of mounting tools included, the seat should fit almost any bike, including standard exercise bikes and Pelotons. That said, a few consumers have complained about compatibility issues so double check before committing to purchase.

As mitigation, the manufacturer is happy to provide a refund during the first 90 days after purchase, so you should be able to purchase this seat with complete confidence, even if you’re buying online.

Things We Like

  • Comfortable but hardwearing
  • Outstanding overall value
  • Choice of eight colors

Things We Dislike

  • Not a universal fit

11. GREAN Comfortable Bike Seat

GREAN-Comfortable-Bike-Seat-Cushion

Features

  • Material: Faux leather
  • Weight: 2.1 pounds
  • Dimensions: 9.7 x 8 x 3.7 inches

GREAN produces some excellent bike gear that’s priced very keenly without stiffing you on the performance front.

The first concession to comfort comes with the inclusion of shock absorbing balls designed to give you a smoother ride whatever the road conditions.

Inside the seat is some plush and responsive memory foam, ideal for anyone who spends lengthy periods cycling and finds that regular bike saddles become too uncomfy.

Although men and women can buy sex-specific saddles, the design of this is ideal for both sexes.

If you encounter any issues with this seat, the manufacturer has a reputation for swift and helpful customer service, something we can’t say about all of the opposition. The returns policy is also straightforward.

Suitable for just about all types of bikes, you can confidently purchase this seat online without worrying about compatibility.

The only real complaint we have about this seat is that build quality issues can develop over time, but you need to be realistic at this price point.

Easy to mount with no special DIY skills or tools included, you’ll be on the road or trail in no time, and you should enjoy a much more comfortable ride thanks to this great GREAN saddle.

Things We Like

  • Features shock-absorbing balls
  • Thickly padded memory foam
  • Responsive customer service

Things We Dislike

  • Build quality issues reported

12. Wikktop Bike Seat

Wittkop-Bike-Seat

Features

  • Material: Waterproof foam
  • Weight: 1.6 pounds
  • Dimensions: 11.2 x 7.3 x 4.1 inches

Wikktop offers a bike seat that’s intended to place your comfort uppermost, but does it deliver or is it a waste of money?

In terms of pricing, this is a mid-range option. In return for digging slightly deeper, you’ll get a seat made from premium materials and capable of returning years of faithful service.

The pad is completely waterproof, allowing you to cycle with confidence in all weather conditions.

Whether you have a regular bike or an electric bike, you’ll appreciate the memory foam packed inside this saddle. This will settle and conform to the curves of your body, guaranteeing you a snug and comfortable ride, even if you often cycle long distances.

Airflow is highly effective and ideal for anyone who spends long spells in the saddle.

Although this seat is marketed as being suitable for men and women, we feel it makes a far better choice for female cyclists than for males.

If you’re still in any doubt about this bike saddle, consider the fact that this brand has been in business since the late 1800s. For German-made excellence and comfort above that offered by many saddles in this market segment, you can’t go wrong with Wikktop.

Things We Like

  • Efficient airflow system
  • Completely waterproof
  • Over a century of brand heritage

Things We Dislike

  • Not the best saddle for men

13. SZXSSDY Soft Bike Saddle

SZXSDY-Comfortable-Bike-Seat-Bicycle-Saddle

Features

  • Material: Foam and leather
  • Weight: 2 pounds
  • Dimensions: 9.84 x 8.15 x 5.7 inches

The strangely named SZXSSDY Store offers this soft bike saddle, but how does it acquit itself in a crowded market?

Firstly, this saddle is designed for larger riders due to the added width. If you are smaller, you’ll still appreciate the extra comfort provided by this oversized seat.

Made from real leather and foam, you might be surprised by just how little this comfy bike saddle costs.

Suitable for mountain bikes, road bikes, and BMXs, this seat doesn’t work well with indoor bikes. We review plenty of suitable options above if you enjoy spinning or indoor cycling.

The frame of this seat is made from a carbon metal, delivering excellent durability and rigidity without weighing your bike down.

Although this seat is a neat solution for riders of both sexes, women may find it extra-comfy.

The fit is claimed to be universal, but we encountered a few gripes from disgruntled customers who ran into issues with compatibility.

Both ventilation and shock absorption are commendable, completing an effective all-round package that’s priced in line with almost everyone’s budget.

Things We Like

  • Padded but long-lasting
  • Super-comfy for female riders
  • Ventilation and shock absorption

Things We Dislike

  • Some claimed fitting issues

14. Schwinn Comfort Bike Seat

Schwinn-Comfort-Bike-Seat

Features

  • Material: Nylon and foam
  • Weight: 2.4 pounds
  • Dimensions: 14.5 x 5 x 11 inches

To round out our collection of the best comfortable bike seats, we have a model from design legends Schwinn. Their vintage-styled contemporary bikes are famous the world over, but how does this saddle shape up?

The first thing to bear in mind is that this seat is a little heavier than some of the competition. If you are looking for speed and aerodynamics in addition to comfort when you’re riding, we suggest exploring some of the more lightweight saddles we review above.

The nylon and foam build is available in a range of finishes to coordinate with your bike. This version is black and designed for commuters seeking comfort above all other factors.

Inside the saddle is an abundance of memory foam designed to smoothen your ride. The foam will also give you some welcome support in the perineal area.

Compatibility is broad with this seat fitting most bikes. Although it is a very comfortable saddle, larger riders may find it slightly restrictive. We review several extra-wide and oversized seats above if that’s what you’re looking for.

As you would expect from a brand with the prestige of Schwinn, build quality is impressive and you can expect to get plenty of faithful service from this comfortable bike seat without needing to break the bank.

Things We Like

  • Ultra-wide saddle
  • Dense and soft padding
  • Almost universal fit

Things We Dislike

  • Not great for larger riders

FAQs

1) How high should my bike seat be?

All bike seats should be positioned to enable you to achieve full leg extension while pedaling. If you find your knee is bent when the pedal is at the lowest point, you should raise your seat position. If, on the other hand, you feel as though you are overextending yourself while paddling, lower the position of the seat.

2) Are all bike seats a universal fit?

Most bike seats will fit most bikes. We draw your attention to this throughout our reviews and flag any compatibility issues.

3) How do I install my bike seat?

Installing a bike seat is straightforward. First, unscrew the bolts situated in the clamp on the bottom of your saddle. This will enable you to remove the old saddle from the seat post. You might need to lift and rotate the top clamp in order to achieve this. Clear all dust and debris and then fit your new seat. Place the rails of your saddle on the seat post. You may first need to grease underneath the bolts. This will minimize creaking when you are pedaling. Put the clamp back over the rails, tighten the screws, and you’re good to go.

4) What is the best bike saddle for recreational cycling?

If you often take short recreational bike rides, whether on an urban bike, a commuter bike, or a cruiser, look for a saddle specifically intended for this purpose. Saddles should be wide and include soft padding. The nose of these saddles is sometimes quite short, and they often feature springs for added comfort and shock absorption.

5) What is the best bike saddle for road bikes?

If you enjoy racing or you ride lengthy distances on the road, look for a long and thin saddle with minimal padding to help you maximize power transfer while pedaling.

6) What is the best bike saddle for mountain bikes?

When riding a mountain bike, you will sometimes be standing on the pedals and sometimes be crouched right back in a more tucked position. These varied positions mean you’ll need a saddle intended for mountain bikes featuring extra padding for your sit bones, an aerodynamic shape, and a durable waterproof cover.

7) What is the best bike saddle for touring?

If you ride long distances on a touring bike, the best comfortable bike seat will be somewhere between the design of a road bike saddle and a mountain bike saddle. The nose will long and narrow. Padding should cushion your tail bone.

8) What is the best bike saddle for commuting?

Comfortable commuter bike saddles will be nicely padded and weatherproofed for confident riding in all weather conditions.


Conclusion

We hope that today’s guide has shown you how to easily and confidently pick a bike saddle designed with your comfort uppermost in mind.

While your bike may come bundled with a decent saddle, it is far more likely to be supplied with one that’s not primarily intended for comfort. Refer to our buying guide above before pulling out your credit card and be sure to pick the right type of saddle for your bike. Most of the seats we review today work for indoor and outdoor bikes, and most are compatible with mountain bikes, road bikes, and commuter bikes.

Before you head off today, take a moment to bookmark Florida Cycling. We have a very busy content schedule for the coming months. Pop back any time you need guidance on any aspect of cycling. We hope to see you soon!

Rate this post

Leave a Comment